I’ve spoken to survivors of deadly Channel crossings – they will try again

Asylum seekers in a small boat trying to cross the English Channel
Archival photo of asylum seekers crossing the English Channel (Picture: Dan Kitwood/Getty Images)

Earlier this week, Keir Starmer spent the day exchanging smiles, pleasantries, and tips on migration from Italy’s far-right leader.

But I think he would have been far better served spending the afternoon with our volunteers in Calais – where I’m based – speaking to the real experts on migration. 

Those who are experiencing it first-hand.

If our Prime Minister had spent the day on the ground here, he would have met survivors of the latest tragedy in the English Channel that happened 24 hours before his visit to Italy, when eight people died trying to cross to England

Had he visited refugees in Calais, Starmer would have heard first-hand from those rescued during that disaster. He would have heard from men, women and children who watched their friends and family drown in the Channel. 

Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer with Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni
Keir Starmer spent the day exchanging smiles, pleasantries, and tips on migration from Italy’s far-right leader (Picture: Phil Noble/PA Wire)

He would have heard from a man, who in the chaos of the rescue, lost the friend with whom he had travelled from Sudan after their homes were destroyed in the civil war.

It was a journey that took them months, and ended in tragedy.

This man was racked with the guilt that he had survived, yet his friend hadn’t. 

TOPSHOT - This photograph taken on September 15, 2024 shows the damaged migrants' boat after a failed attempt to cross the English Channel that led to the death of 8 people near the beach of Ambleteuse, northern France. Eight migrants died when their clandestine boat sank off Ambleteuse (Pas-de-Calais) on September 15, 2024, bringing to over 45 the number of would-be exiles to Britain who died in the Channel in 2024. (Photo by Bernard BARRON / AFP) (Photo by BERNARD BARRON/AFP via Getty Images)
The remnants of the boat where eight people died crossing the English Channel (Picture: BERNARD BARRON/AFP via Getty Images)

These are the conversations I have had daily with communities here in my three years delivering humanitarian aid with Care4Calais – a refugee charity working with refugees in the UK and France.

Conversations with a community who are faced with the bleakest choice; to get on a boat to cross the world’s busiest shipping lane in search of safety or face imprisonment, torture, or death back home.

Up Next

Every person I have met here has told me that if there was any other way, they wouldn’t get into a boat. 

Every person I have met has had no choice but to flee their homes, leaving behind family, friends and belongings.

Every person I have met here is so much more than the journey they are on and their current need for safety. They’re a person, not a statistic. 

Tents in Calais
Tents in Calais (Picture: Care4Calais)

Speaking to two people who were on the boat when the eight migrants died, they asked me why there was no safe way for them to reach the UK.

Both said they dreamed of being home with their family but that their homes were destroyed, and they had faced harassment in each country in which they arrived.

Now they had experienced the unimaginable – losing friends less than 30 miles from the UK. Heartbreakingly, they told me they had no choice but to try to make the journey again.

DOVER, ENGLAND - SEPTEMBER 17: Inflatable dinghies and off-board motors believed to have been used by migrants to cross the English channel from France to England are stored in a Home Office compound on September 17, 2024 in Dover, England. Eight people died attempting to cross the English Channel from France on September 15, bringing the total number of those killed attempting to cross the English Channel this year to 45, according to the UN's International Organisation for Migration. (Photo by Dan Kitwood/Getty Images)
Inflatable dinghies believed to have been used by migrants to cross the English channel are stored in a Home Office compound (Picture: Dan Kitwood/Getty Images)

By spending one day speaking to the communities we work with in Calais, our political leaders would immediately understand why – despite their thirst to look tough on migration – their so-called deterrents change nothing. 

Security measures, including the constant cycle of aggressive police evictions of the camps, do nothing to deter people from wanting to claim asylum in the UK – they only force people to take more risks to do so.

Up Next

This approach isn’t protecting anyone, it’s costing lives. 

Eight people lost their lives in Sunday’s tragedy. Two weeks ago, 12 people, including a pregnant woman and children, died in similar circumstances

Each loss of life was preventable. And I don’t believe these things would happen if our political leaders were willing to act with an ounce of compassion and humanity.

French gendarme use a tractor to pull a damaged migrants' boat after a failed attempt to cross the English Channel
Authorities using a tractor to pull a damaged migrants’ boat after a failed attempt to cross the English Channel (Picture: BERNARD BARRON/AFP via Getty Images)

We are part of a community where grieving has become commonplace. There should be nothing normal about a vigil, but here in Calais it is becoming the norm. The grief leaves us heartbroken. The anger fuels us to continue.

No one chooses to cross the English Channel in a small boat because it’s their preferred mode of transportation to claim asylum in the UK. It’s their only option.

The last UK Government effectively cut every safe route for people to claim asylum before arriving.

Care4Calais

For more information about Care4Calais and the work they do, visit their website here.

If, for example, you are fleeing war in Sudan, or trouble in Eritrea, there is no way for you to claim asylum without physically being in the UK. 

It’s the absence of safe routes that has fuelled Channel crossings. 

And it’s human beings, many of whom have already survived unimaginable horrors such as war and torture, that are losing their lives.

Crew members of a French rescue vessel look after a group of migrants on an inflatable dinghy
If Keir Starmer’s dehumanisation of refugees continues, more lives could be lost (Picture: REUTERS/Pascal Rossignol/File Photo)

All of this would be fixed by introducing safe routes. Two and a half years ago, when Russia invaded Ukraine, our team in Calais supported Ukranians who were arriving in Calais in the hope of seeking safety in the UK. 

Very quickly, the then-UK Government created the Ukrainian visa scheme and almost overnight the Ukrainian refugee community here dispersed. With the option of applying for a travel visa, no Ukranian was forced to pay a smuggling gang to cross the Channel – they had the choice of a safe route.

If the new Government wants to tackle crossings, and end the preventable loss of life on our border, they will introduce those same routes for people fleeing other war-torn countries. 

If Keir Starmer’s dehumanisation of refugees continues, more lives could be lost.

So Prime Minister, the choice is yours.

Related Posts


This will close in 0 seconds